Pig World
  • News
      • Animal Health
      • Breeding
      • Business
      • Environment
      • EU
      • Food Safety
      • Housing
      • Marketing
      • NPA
      • National Pig Awards
      • New Products
      • Nutrition
      • People
      • Pig Fair
      • Politics
      • Training & Education
      • Welfare
  • Features
    • Animal Health
    • Breeding
    • Environment
    • Farm Visits
    • Herd Recording
    • Housing
    • Marketing
    • Nutrition
    • Products
    • Training
  • Comment
    • AHDB Pork
    • Chris Fogden
    • Dennis Bridgeford
    • Peter Crichton
    • Red Robin
    • Veterinary View
    • Zoe Davies, NPA
  • Numbers
  • Pig Prices
  • Magazines
    • November 2026
    • 2026 National Pig Awards supplement
    • October 2026
    • September 2026
    • August 2026
    • 2026 Pig Health supplement
    • July 2026
    • June 2026
    • 2026 Innovation supplement
    • 2026 British Pig & Poultry Fair guide
    • May 2026
    • April 2026
    • March 2026
    • 2026 Buildings supplement
    • February 2026
    • 2026 Pig Nutrition supplement
    • January 2026
    • December 2025
    • November 2025
    • 2025 National Pig Awards supplement
    • October 2025
    • September 2025
    • August 2025
    • 2025 Maximising Pig Health supplement
    • July 2025
    • June 2025
    • 2025 Innovation supplement
    • May 2025
    • April 2025
    • March 2025
    • 2025 Buildings supplement
    • February 2025
    • 2025 Nutrition Supplement
    • January 2025
    • December 2024
    • November 2024
    • 2024 National Pig Awards supplement
    • October 2024
    • September 2024
    • August 2024
    • 2024 Pig Health supplement
    • July 2024
    • June 2024
    • 2024 Innovation supplement
    • 2024 Pig & Poultry Fair Guide
    • May 2024
    • April 2024
    • 2024 Buildings Supplement
    • March 2024
    • 2024 Pig Nutrition supplement
    • February 2024
    • January 2024
    • December 2023
    • November 2023
    • 2023 National Pig Awards supplement
    • October 2023
    • September 2023
    • Health Supplement
  • Suppliers
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job
    • Manage Jobs
  • Classified
  • Events
    • Pigs Tomorrow
    • National Pig Awards
    • ADOPT funding webinar
Subscribe
Pig WorldPig World
  • News
      • Animal Health
      • Breeding
      • Business
      • Environment
      • EU
      • Food Safety
      • Housing
      • Marketing
      • NPA
      • National Pig Awards
      • New Products
      • Nutrition
      • People
      • Pig Fair
      • Politics
      • Training & Education
      • Welfare
  • Features
    • Animal Health
    • Breeding
    • Environment
    • Farm Visits
    • Herd Recording
    • Housing
    • Marketing
    • Nutrition
    • Products
    • Training
  • Comment
    • AHDB Pork
    • Chris Fogden
    • Dennis Bridgeford
    • Peter Crichton
    • Red Robin
    • Veterinary View
    • Zoe Davies, NPA
  • Numbers
  • Pig Prices
  • Magazines
    1. November 2026
    2. 2026 National Pig Awards supplement
    3. October 2026
    4. September 2026
    5. August 2026
    6. 2026 Pig Health supplement
    7. July 2026
    8. June 2026
    9. 2026 Innovation supplement
    10. 2026 British Pig & Poultry Fair guide
    11. May 2026
    12. April 2026
    13. March 2026
    14. 2026 Buildings supplement
    15. February 2026
    16. 2026 Pig Nutrition supplement
    17. January 2026
    18. December 2025
    19. November 2025
    20. 2025 National Pig Awards supplement
    21. October 2025
    22. September 2025
    23. August 2025
    24. 2025 Maximising Pig Health supplement
    25. July 2025
    26. June 2025
    27. 2025 Innovation supplement
    28. May 2025
    29. April 2025
    30. March 2025
    31. 2025 Buildings supplement
    32. February 2025
    33. 2025 Nutrition Supplement
    34. January 2025
    35. December 2024
    36. November 2024
    37. 2024 National Pig Awards supplement
    38. October 2024
    39. September 2024
    40. August 2024
    41. 2024 Pig Health supplement
    42. July 2024
    43. June 2024
    44. 2024 Innovation supplement
    45. 2024 Pig & Poultry Fair Guide
    46. May 2024
    47. April 2024
    48. 2024 Buildings Supplement
    49. March 2024
    50. 2024 Pig Nutrition supplement
    51. February 2024
    52. January 2024
    53. December 2023
    54. November 2023
    55. 2023 National Pig Awards supplement
    56. October 2023
    57. September 2023
    58. Health Supplement
    Featured

    2026 National Pig Awards supplement now available

    November 2, 2026
    Recent

    2026 National Pig Awards supplement now available

    November 2, 2026

    November 2026 issue of Pig World now available

    November 2, 2026

    October 2026 issue of Pig World now available

    October 5, 2026
  • Suppliers
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job
    • Manage Jobs
  • Classified
  • Events
    • Pigs Tomorrow
    • National Pig Awards
    • ADOPT funding webinar
LinkedIn X (Twitter)
Pig World
CO2 in abattoirs

MPs challenge Defra minister over scientific basis of CO2 ban proposals

Alistair DriverBy Alistair DriverOctober 29, 20265 Mins Read
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

Defra has been accused by MPs of ‘putting the cart before the horse’ in launching proposals to ban carbon dioxide (CO2) in abattoirs without clear scientific evidence that there are commercially viable alternatives.

On Monday, Defra launched a consultation on proposals to replace high-concentration CO2 as a means of stunning pigs with alternatives such as argon or electrical stunning. It stated a preference for a transition period of a maximum of three years, which has been described as ‘totally unworkable’ by the NPA, while the abattoir sector has warned the policy could undermine UK food security.

Food security minister Stephen Morgan was challenged on the proposed ban during his appearance in front of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (EFRA) committee on Tuesday.

Robust evidence

Labour MP Josh Newbury welcomed the government’s ‘visionary’ animal welfare strategy but stressed that, in order to achieve real welfare gains, any changes must be ‘based on robust evidence’.

He pointed to comments in the consultation that ‘both argon and electric stunning are proven to substantially reduce animal suffering’. However, he highlighted passages in the Animal Welfare Committee’s report on which the policy is based, which stated that ‘exposure to argon still causes vocalisations and sometimes escape attempts’.

“It takes longer for pigs to lose consciousness, which could have welfare implications and would certainly have commercial impacts for abattoirs,” Mr Newbury said. “It goes on to say that the CCTV the committee saw wasn’t in the gas system itself, so it was inadequate to properly assess their welfare.”

He also highlighted the committee’s comments that, in the EU PigStun trial on automated electrical stunning, one fifth of pigs showed signs of consciousness after they had been electrically stunned, and had to be re-stunned, with potential huge welfare implications for pigs and risk to staff.

“So, given all of that, can you, hand on heart at this point, say that the evidence base is strong enough to bring that consultation forward?” Mr Newbury asked the minister.

Engagement

Stephen Morgan

Mr Morgan said the government had negotiated with the industry in advance of the proposals going out for public consultation.

“I think it’s really important that we have that engagement with industry, and obviously we are encouraging people to respond to the consultation,” he said. “I’m very keen to make sure we do deliver on our manifesto commitments, as we set out at the election, but also to work with industry around mitigating risks and challenges.”

Mr Newbury then stressed the need for a ‘full industry-led trial with independent oversight’ to address the ‘huge gaps in the evidence’ and asked the minister why this wasn’t gathered before the consultation was released.

He added that NPA officials had told him at a meeting on CO2 in abattoirs in parliament on Monday that concerns they had raised in various meetings with Defra ‘did not seem to have had any bearing on what’s in the consultation document, whatsoever’.

He again pressed Mr Morgan on whether he will be engaging with producers and abattoirs, predicting that their concerns are ‘only going to grow louder and louder in the coming weeks’. “There’s a lot going on in the industry and this is another thing that is being heaped on them,” he said.

Cart before the horse

EFRA chair Alistair Carmichael picked up on theme, expressing surprise that he had heard directly of the concerns of the NPA and others, but the minister seemingly hadn’t.

“You’ve published the consultation, but you’re consulting on stuff that you haven’t properly trialled. Is that not putting the cart before the horse?” he asked.

Mr Morgan and Defra’s farming director, Mike Rowe, alongside him were unable to answer when Mr Carmichael asked whether other countries, such as the Netherlands and Denmark, were considering similar bans. Mr Newbury added that the US has only just moved to CO2 stunning and was ‘baffled’ by the UK’s move.

Conservative MP Charlie Dewhirst, formerly of the NPA, noted that the UK currenty has ‘readily available’ supplies of CO2, despite the consultation’s argument that the move would address the pressure on CO2 availability.

He asked where Defra would expect to import argon and nitrogen, another potential alternative, from. When the Defra official said they would have to get back to him on that, Mr Dewhirst pointed out that Russia is a ‘major producer of those gases’. “And that would mean our domestic food security is further compromised by relying on the Russian imports. So, that, in itself, would seem to be a wrong way about it,” he said.

Mr Dewhirst also challenged Defra on the proposed transition period of two or three years, pointing out that the pig sector already has 15,000 pigs backed up on farm this autumn, a situation likely to get worse.

“The transition would require shutting down the abattoirs for a conversion – these are abattoirs that are running at full capacity, trying to deal with the situation with the market, as it is. Two to three years would be unworkable, and would create additional welfare problems on farm, because there wouldn’t be the throughput capacity in the abattoirs for the pigs we’re already producing.”

Minister’s response

Throughout these questions, Mr Morgan and Mr Rowe struggled to directly address the details of the MPs’ concerns. However, the minister repeatedly stressed that he has engaged with the pig industry and will continue to do so on these issues, and that the consultation is an opportunity for all these issues to be raised.

He confirmed that Defra will be hosting a pig industry summit to discuss the current issues facing the sector, which are likely to include the proposed CO2 ban.

“My understanding is that the proposal would have significant improvements to pig welfare at the time of killing,” he said. “I will commit to seeing the sector further to get into that detail and make sure that everyone contributes to the consultation.”

Share. LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Email
Previous ArticleScottish pig farmer and Nuffield scholar applies global insight to big pig question
Next Article NFU Scotland calls for review of imports as overseas food reliance grows
Alistair Driver

Editor Pig World and the Tribune. National Pig Association webmaster. Former political editor at Farmers Guardian. Occasional media pundit. Brought up on a Leicestershire farm. Works from a shed in Oxfordshire garden.

Read Similar Stories

Pig producer losses grow during Q3 on the back of rising feed costs

November 10, 2026

Red Tractor sets out proposed standards on flexible farrowing, as consultation launched

November 10, 2026

AHDB report on ASF preparedness highlights importance of partnership and effective communications

November 6, 2026
Latest News

Pig producer losses grow during Q3 on the back of rising feed costs

November 10, 2026

Red Tractor sets out proposed standards on flexible farrowing, as consultation launched

November 10, 2026

New pig innovations on show at EuroTier 2026

November 9, 2026
Sponsored Content

Healthy lungs, Healthy Performance: Protecting pig performance with Cirbloc® M Hyo and Ceva Lung Program

October 30, 2026

Want more from your sows? It’s time to add claw lesion checks into your herd protocol

October 1, 2026
Current Pig Industry jobs
  • Assistant Farm Manager – Ref 1952 Worcestershire

    • Worcestershire
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
  • Pig Stockperson – Ref 1951 West Yorkshire

    • West Yorkshire
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
  • Senior Pig Stockperson

    • Lincolnshire
    • Wold Farms Ltd
    • Full Time
GETTING IN TOUCH
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Meet The Editors
  • About Us
  • Email Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Reuse permissions
OUR SOCIAL CHANNELS
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
PARTNER EVENTS
RELATED SITES
  • Farmers Weekly
  • Agronomist & Arable Farmer
  • Farm Contractor
  • National Pig Awards
  • Pigs Tomorrow
  • Poultry News
  • Weekly Tribune
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
© 2024 MA Agriculture Ltd, a Mark Allen Group company

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.