Pig World
  • News
      • Animal Health
      • Breeding
      • Business
      • Environment
      • EU
      • Food Safety
      • Housing
      • Marketing
      • NPA
      • National Pig Awards
      • New Products
      • Nutrition
      • People
      • Pig Fair
      • Politics
      • Training & Education
      • Welfare
  • Features
    • Animal Health
    • Breeding
    • Environment
    • Farm Visits
    • Herd Recording
    • Housing
    • Marketing
    • Nutrition
    • Products
    • Training
  • Comment
    • AHDB Pork
    • Chris Fogden
    • Dennis Bridgeford
    • Peter Crichton
    • Red Robin
    • Veterinary View
    • Zoe Davies, NPA
  • Numbers
  • Pig Prices
  • Magazines
    • December 2023
    • November 2023
    • National Pig Awards Supplement 2023
    • October 2023
    • September 2023
    • Health Supplement
    • August 2023
    • Pigs Tomorrow Supplement
  • Suppliers
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job
    • Manage Jobs
  • Equipment
  • Events
    • Pigs Tomorrow
    • National Pig Awards
Subscribe Podcast
Pig WorldPig World
  • News
      • Animal Health
      • Breeding
      • Business
      • Environment
      • EU
      • Food Safety
      • Housing
      • Marketing
      • NPA
      • National Pig Awards
      • New Products
      • Nutrition
      • People
      • Pig Fair
      • Politics
      • Training & Education
      • Welfare
  • Features
    • Animal Health
    • Breeding
    • Environment
    • Farm Visits
    • Herd Recording
    • Housing
    • Marketing
    • Nutrition
    • Products
    • Training
  • Comment
    • AHDB Pork
    • Chris Fogden
    • Dennis Bridgeford
    • Peter Crichton
    • Red Robin
    • Veterinary View
    • Zoe Davies, NPA
  • Numbers
  • Pig Prices
  • Magazines
    1. December 2023
    2. November 2023
    3. National Pig Awards Supplement 2023
    4. October 2023
    5. September 2023
    6. Health Supplement
    7. August 2023
    8. Pigs Tomorrow Supplement
    Featured

    Pig World – December 2023

    December 1, 2023
    Recent

    Pig World – December 2023

    December 1, 2023

    National Pig Awards Supplement 2023

    October 31, 2023

    Pig World – November 2023

    October 31, 2023
  • Suppliers
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job
    • Manage Jobs
  • Equipment
  • Events
    • Pigs Tomorrow
    • National Pig Awards
LinkedIn X (Twitter)
Pig World
Graeme Kirk

April 2015: The growing influence of the anti-livestock lobby

PW ReportersBy PW ReportersApril 2, 20153 Mins Read
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

The United States government may think it’s in charge of the world’s biggest superpower, but even it has proved to be susceptible to the influence of special interest groups representing those who would rather animals weren’t raised for meat. Incredibly, controversy is raging in this great farming nation because of proposed dietary advice currently under review by the US Department of Health and Human Services (USHHS) and the US Department of Agriculture (USDA).

Every five years, the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee (DGAC) – established jointly by the USHHS and USDA – is charged with setting advice on healthy eating in the publication Dietary Guidelines for Americans; and the latest recommendations have upset America’s meat industry.

This isn’t exactly a surprise; before the latest guidelines were even published for comment, the North American Meat Institute (NAMI) had warned that lean meat would be excluded from the recommendations, and claimed the decision had been made behind closed doors during the lunchbreak at the DGAC’s December meeting.

With the 2015 guidelines now open for consulation, NAMI has described the approach to meat as flawed and nonsensical. In particular, it takes issue with the suggestion in the document that diets should be “lower in red meat and processed meats”.

The organisations’ primary “beef” is that the guidelines don’t recognise the positive role lean meat has to play in a healthy diet, but there’s an ever greater issue at play.

“The committee’s contradictory advice to reduce processed meats is also nonsensical,” NAMI says, “especially given data the committee reviewed about the Mediterranean diet. Followers of the Mediterranean diet – the diet hailed by so many for its good nutrition and health outcomes – consume twice as many processed meats as included in the USDA’s food patterns.”

But it turns out what really sits at the heart of this issue has little to do with human health at all. DGAC says its advice is based on research that suggests diets that are higher in plant-based foods and lower in animal-based foods are more sustainable and associated with less environmental impact than the current US diet.

NAMI president Barry Carpenter’s pulled no punches when he commented: “DGAC’s foray into the murky waters of sustainability is well beyond its scope and expertise.”

US politicians have also now joined the debate. A group of 30 senators has written to the HHS and USDA urging them to: “consider the most relevant nutrition scientific literature, and reject the committee’s inconsistent conclusions and recommendations regarding the role of lean red meat in a healthy diet”.

Meanwhile, the agriculture committee chairman and chairwoman of the subcommittee on nutrition in the House of Congress are both demanding the consultation period on the DGAC guidelines be doubled to 90 days.

> Graeme Kirk has been editor of Pig World since March 2013. Born into a farming family in South-west Scotland, he’s been an agricultural journalist for nearly 30 years

Share. LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Email
Previous ArticleBPEX confidence survey highlights current industry pressures
Next Article Research aims to identify pigs with lameness pre-disposition
PW Reporters

Read Similar Stories

August 2016: Is cutting animal populations really the answer to climate change?

July 27, 2016

New retailer project may reveal a few home truths

July 3, 2016

June 2016: United Nations report calls for cuts in meat consumption

June 6, 2016
Latest News

UK pork production forecast to edge up, as Robobank sets out global protein production trends

December 1, 2023

Pig World – December 2023

December 1, 2023

New Defra Secretary unveils £45m in farm funding opportunities

November 30, 2023
Sponsored Content

Porcine Circovirus: Is Clinical Disease Just the Tip of the Iceberg?

November 1, 2023
Current Pig Industry jobs
  • Senior Pig Stockperson – Ref 1473 Scottish Borders

    • Scottish Borders
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
  • Pig Unit Manager – Ref 1472 Yorkshire

    • North Yorkshire
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
  • Pig Stockperson – Ref 1471 Norfolk

    • Norfolk
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
GETTING IN TOUCH
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Meet The Editors
  • About Us
  • Email Newsletters
OUR SOCIAL CHANNELS
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
PARTNER EVENTS
RELATED SITES
  • Farmers Weekly
  • Agronomist & Arable Farmer
  • Farm Contractor
  • National Pig Awards
  • Pigs Tomorrow
  • Poultry News
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
© 2023 Lewis Business Media. All Rights Reserved | Lewis Business Media, Suite A, Arun House, Office Village, River Way, Uckfield, TN22 1SL

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.