Pig World
  • News
      • Animal Health
      • Breeding
      • Business
      • Environment
      • EU
      • Food Safety
      • Housing
      • Marketing
      • NPA
      • National Pig Awards
      • New Products
      • Nutrition
      • People
      • Pig Fair
      • Politics
      • Training & Education
      • Welfare
  • Features
    • Animal Health
    • Breeding
    • Environment
    • Farm Visits
    • Herd Recording
    • Housing
    • Marketing
    • Nutrition
    • Products
    • Training
  • Comment
    • AHDB Pork
    • Chris Fogden
    • Dennis Bridgeford
    • Peter Crichton
    • Red Robin
    • Veterinary View
    • Zoe Davies, NPA
  • Numbers
  • Pig Prices
  • Magazines
    • June 2025
    • 2025 Innovation supplement
    • May 2025
    • April 2025
    • March 2025
    • 2025 Buildings supplement
    • February 2025
    • 2025 Nutrition Supplement
    • January 2025
    • December 2024
    • November 2024
    • 2025 National Pig Awards supplement
    • October 2024
    • September 2024
    • August 2024
    • 2024 Pig Health supplement
    • July 2024
    • June 2024
    • 2024 Innovation supplement
    • 2024 Pig & Poultry Fair Guide
    • May 2024
    • April 2024
    • 2024 Buildings Supplement
    • March 2024
    • 2024 Pig Nutrition supplement
    • February 2024
    • January 2024
    • December 2023
    • November 2023
    • 2023 National Pig Awards supplement
    • October 2023
    • September 2023
    • Health Supplement
  • Suppliers
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job
    • Manage Jobs
  • Classified
  • Events
    • Pigs Tomorrow
    • National Pig Awards
Podcast
Pig WorldPig World
  • News
      • Animal Health
      • Breeding
      • Business
      • Environment
      • EU
      • Food Safety
      • Housing
      • Marketing
      • NPA
      • National Pig Awards
      • New Products
      • Nutrition
      • People
      • Pig Fair
      • Politics
      • Training & Education
      • Welfare
  • Features
    • Animal Health
    • Breeding
    • Environment
    • Farm Visits
    • Herd Recording
    • Housing
    • Marketing
    • Nutrition
    • Products
    • Training
  • Comment
    • AHDB Pork
    • Chris Fogden
    • Dennis Bridgeford
    • Peter Crichton
    • Red Robin
    • Veterinary View
    • Zoe Davies, NPA
  • Numbers
  • Pig Prices
  • Magazines
    1. June 2025
    2. 2025 Innovation supplement
    3. May 2025
    4. April 2025
    5. March 2025
    6. 2025 Buildings supplement
    7. February 2025
    8. 2025 Nutrition Supplement
    9. January 2025
    10. December 2024
    11. November 2024
    12. 2025 National Pig Awards supplement
    13. October 2024
    14. September 2024
    15. August 2024
    16. 2024 Pig Health supplement
    17. July 2024
    18. June 2024
    19. 2024 Innovation supplement
    20. 2024 Pig & Poultry Fair Guide
    21. May 2024
    22. April 2024
    23. 2024 Buildings Supplement
    24. March 2024
    25. 2024 Pig Nutrition supplement
    26. February 2024
    27. January 2024
    28. December 2023
    29. November 2023
    30. 2023 National Pig Awards supplement
    31. October 2023
    32. September 2023
    33. Health Supplement
    Featured

    June 2025 issue of Pig World now available

    June 4, 2025
    Recent

    June 2025 issue of Pig World now available

    June 4, 2025

    2025 Innovation supplement now available

    June 4, 2025

    May 2025 issue of Pig World now available

    May 1, 2025
  • Suppliers
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job
    • Manage Jobs
  • Classified
  • Events
    • Pigs Tomorrow
    • National Pig Awards
LinkedIn X (Twitter)
Pig World
John Gadds Pig Pen

Variation in slaughter weights – does “topping” help?

John GaddBy John GaddFebruary 18, 20144 Mins Read
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

Everyone suffers from a variation in slaughter weights to a greater or lesser extent, and one solution is to try “topping”, that is removing pigs to a spare pen or on to slaughter that look 5% to 10% ahead of the rest of their companions in a pen, writes John Gadd.

This is sometimes done about seven to 10 days before slaughter when the pens are beginning to look distinctly crowded. Overcrowding tends to slow up the growth of the whole pen, and can result in too much variation in slaughterweights.

As this practice seems to be a growing trend, I did some measurements in 2010 with co-operating farmers as I was unsure whether some forms of topping were a good idea. This was because in too many cases there were insufficient spare pens available to keep the selected pigs apart from those in other pens doing very well, and too much scrapping occurred.

Topping or “selective removal” is done for a variety of reasons. First, there’s removal to avoid overweights. This is essential, of course, in order to avoid a contract penalty, but those chosen must be loaded straight on to the transporter and not kept mixed in one holding pen overnight ready for the early-morning collection. Even this short period together would cause scrapping and stress.

 Second, some producers deliberately move some of the fastest-growing pigs to another pen seven to 10 days before estimated shipping date if they have suitable accommodation is available. Two UK producers I work with constructed straw bale pens with internal divisions for this purpose, and were careful not to mix growers from different pens together thus avoiding skin damage from scrapping and antagonistic stress offsetting growth rate. Topping adherents claim that the growth rate of the moved pigs improves by about 20g/day compared to not moving them, and those left behind improve by up to 50g/day thanks to the extra space and reduced competition for feed.

Third, there conventional topping, which is sending some of the fastest-growing pigs to slaughter about a week sooner than normal. These pigs are shipped within the contract weight range, but may be towards its lower end. Several of my Continental clients have tried this, and I checked their returns. Dependent on the terms of each farm’s contract, some 4.5kg of potential deadweight return was sacrificed, costing 6.5 euros/pig – say 13 euros for the two biggest pigs sent on early from each increasingly overcrowded pen of 15 pigs. The remaining 13 benefited from more room and better access to feed – even ad-lib feed – but they still saved only half a day occupancy from their faster growth, plus two euros-worth of food for the whole 13 pigs. And yes, you can add to this a week’s food saved from those shipped early, but this only recouped one-third of the 13 euros lost income per pen from the meat they would have put on during that final week.

This leads me to two conclusions. First, if you are forced into topping, keep an eye on the economic returns. The heavier you ship every pig as near to, but under, the contract overweight cut-off point, the better (my next blog will describe a useful method of achieving this). And second, on all of the farms, topping carried out sensibly and well did have the physical benefits as claimed by the protagonists, but it did not always pay.

This is a classic example that while published physical performance benefits may well be found in any research trial, when the econometrics are added in, then these favourable physical performances may need to be looked at anew in profit terms.

So, playing devil’s advocate, I’d have to say: 1, topping seems to work when the pigs were overstocked, but they shouldn’t have been in this position in the first place! Surely it’s cheaper not to overstock than to be forced into topping?

And 2, topping does work when there’s spare accommodation available, but again, maybe this should have been filled anyway!

Until I’m persuaded otherwise, have any of you got figures to change my mind? I’m afraid most of the the topping I see on my travels makes me nervous.

Share. LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Email
Previous ArticleKeep vigilant against swine dysentery
Next Article Pork imports and exports higher in December
John Gadd

Read Similar Stories

How to measure light

August 4, 2016

Outdoor sows and bright spring sunshine

August 2, 2016

The benefits of bandwidth piggery ventilation

July 7, 2016
Latest News

Greater onus on farmers to justify autumn spreading, under revised FRfW guidance

June 20, 2025

Opportunity for pig farmers to take part in Just Farmers media workshops

June 20, 2025

Red Tractor research highlights public backing for British food

June 19, 2025
Sponsored Content

THE GATEKEEPER OF RESPIRATORY HEALTH – MYCOPLASMA HYOPNEUMONIAE (M.HYO)

April 30, 2024

Tackle the root cause of PWD with free diagnostic tests

March 1, 2024
Current Pig Industry jobs
  • Farrowing Manager

    • Suffolk
    • Blythburgh Pigs
    • Full Time
  • Pig Stockperson – Ref 1752 Somerset

    • Somerset
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
  • Senior Piggery Stockpersons – Ref 1751 Western Australia

    • Western Australia
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
GETTING IN TOUCH
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Meet The Editors
  • About Us
  • Email Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Reuse permissions
OUR SOCIAL CHANNELS
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
PARTNER EVENTS
RELATED SITES
  • Farmers Weekly
  • Agronomist & Arable Farmer
  • Farm Contractor
  • National Pig Awards
  • Pigs Tomorrow
  • Poultry News
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
© 2024 MA Agriculture Ltd, a Mark Allen Group company

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.