Pig World
  • News
      • Animal Health
      • Breeding
      • Business
      • Environment
      • EU
      • Food Safety
      • Housing
      • Marketing
      • NPA
      • National Pig Awards
      • New Products
      • Nutrition
      • People
      • Pig Fair
      • Politics
      • Training & Education
      • Welfare
  • Features
    • Animal Health
    • Breeding
    • Environment
    • Farm Visits
    • Herd Recording
    • Housing
    • Marketing
    • Nutrition
    • Products
    • Training
  • Comment
    • AHDB Pork
    • Chris Fogden
    • Dennis Bridgeford
    • Peter Crichton
    • Red Robin
    • Veterinary View
    • Zoe Davies, NPA
  • Numbers
  • Pig Prices
  • Magazines
    • June 2025
    • 2025 Innovation supplement
    • May 2025
    • April 2025
    • March 2025
    • 2025 Buildings supplement
    • February 2025
    • 2025 Nutrition Supplement
    • January 2025
    • December 2024
    • November 2024
    • 2025 National Pig Awards supplement
    • October 2024
    • September 2024
    • August 2024
    • 2024 Pig Health supplement
    • July 2024
    • June 2024
    • 2024 Innovation supplement
    • 2024 Pig & Poultry Fair Guide
    • May 2024
    • April 2024
    • 2024 Buildings Supplement
    • March 2024
    • 2024 Pig Nutrition supplement
    • February 2024
    • January 2024
    • December 2023
    • November 2023
    • 2023 National Pig Awards supplement
    • October 2023
    • September 2023
    • Health Supplement
  • Suppliers
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job
    • Manage Jobs
  • Classified
  • Events
    • Pigs Tomorrow
    • National Pig Awards
Podcast
Pig WorldPig World
  • News
      • Animal Health
      • Breeding
      • Business
      • Environment
      • EU
      • Food Safety
      • Housing
      • Marketing
      • NPA
      • National Pig Awards
      • New Products
      • Nutrition
      • People
      • Pig Fair
      • Politics
      • Training & Education
      • Welfare
  • Features
    • Animal Health
    • Breeding
    • Environment
    • Farm Visits
    • Herd Recording
    • Housing
    • Marketing
    • Nutrition
    • Products
    • Training
  • Comment
    • AHDB Pork
    • Chris Fogden
    • Dennis Bridgeford
    • Peter Crichton
    • Red Robin
    • Veterinary View
    • Zoe Davies, NPA
  • Numbers
  • Pig Prices
  • Magazines
    1. June 2025
    2. 2025 Innovation supplement
    3. May 2025
    4. April 2025
    5. March 2025
    6. 2025 Buildings supplement
    7. February 2025
    8. 2025 Nutrition Supplement
    9. January 2025
    10. December 2024
    11. November 2024
    12. 2025 National Pig Awards supplement
    13. October 2024
    14. September 2024
    15. August 2024
    16. 2024 Pig Health supplement
    17. July 2024
    18. June 2024
    19. 2024 Innovation supplement
    20. 2024 Pig & Poultry Fair Guide
    21. May 2024
    22. April 2024
    23. 2024 Buildings Supplement
    24. March 2024
    25. 2024 Pig Nutrition supplement
    26. February 2024
    27. January 2024
    28. December 2023
    29. November 2023
    30. 2023 National Pig Awards supplement
    31. October 2023
    32. September 2023
    33. Health Supplement
    Featured

    June 2025 issue of Pig World now available

    June 4, 2025
    Recent

    June 2025 issue of Pig World now available

    June 4, 2025

    2025 Innovation supplement now available

    June 4, 2025

    May 2025 issue of Pig World now available

    May 1, 2025
  • Suppliers
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job
    • Manage Jobs
  • Classified
  • Events
    • Pigs Tomorrow
    • National Pig Awards
LinkedIn X (Twitter)
Pig World
Animal Health

The large farm debate – why big isn’t bad for the UK pig industry

Alistair DriverBy Alistair DriverAugust 4, 20178 Mins Read
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

The headline said it all: “Rise of mega farms: how the US model of intensive farming is invading the world”.

Last month, The Guardian carried out a joint investigation with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism (BIJ) into the growing number of large farms in the UK. It is all part of a wider narrative linking ‘intensive’ or ‘factory’ farms to many of society’s ills, including ‘cruel’ treatment of farmed animals, excessive antibiotic use, pollution and environmental damage. Large farms are also blamed for putting small ones out of business and adversely affecting local residents.

The Guardian’s environment correspondent, Fiona Harvey, said people were concerned about the rise in large farms because animals were ‘unable to express their natural behaviour, such as outdoor grazing, as they would on a traditional farm’.
“If one animal gets sick, the whole herd has to be treated,” Ms Harvey added.

This article, which sparked a wave of national coverage, coincided with the publication of Compassion in World Farming’s online Factory Farm Map. It highlights hotspots where these ‘crazy and cruel’ farms are most prevalent, although it does not pinpoint individual farms, as was initially feared.

“We are talking about a completely different scale of farming here to what we see in places like the US and Brazil – 750 sows would not be considered large in these places” Dr Georgina Crayford

Are the UK’s farms
getting bigger?

The Guardian/BIJ investigation highlighted a 26% rise in the number of ‘intensive’ poultry and pig farms licensed by the Environment Agency (EA) over the last six years to 1,700. Only 12 counties now have no pig or poultry farms classified as intensive.

The EA’s threshold for ‘intensive’ farms, set for environmental control reasons, is 40,000 poultry places and 2,000 pig places, or 750 sows. But if you take the US definition of concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs) – 1,000 beef cattle, 700 dairy cows, 2,500 pigs (above 25kg), 82,000 laying hens or 125,000 broilers confined on site for more than 45 days a year – the numbers are even less dramatic. There are now 789 ‘mega farms’ in the UK that meet these thresholds, rising perhaps but hardly comparable to the 50,000 CAFOs in the US.

More to the point, certainly as far as pigs are concerned, the large UK farms do not compare with the biggest US units, some of which contain hundreds of thousands of pigs, according to National Pig Association (NPA) senior policy advisor Georgina Crayford.

“There is no comparison. We are talking about a completely different scale of farming here to what we see in places like the US and Brazil – 750 sows would not be considered large in these places. Our large units will also face much stricter rules, particularly on welfare, than in most other major pig producing countries,” she said.

Campaigners claim UK farms are becoming more like huge US farms
Campaigners claim UK farms are becoming more like huge US farms

Economic drivers
The gradual trend towards larger farms in the UK is part of a long-running social and economic trend.
Around 85% of UK pigs are kept on holdings of at least 1,000 pigs, with around 820 farms of 100 or more sows now accounting for 89% of the national breeding herd, according to data from the latest Pig Health and Welfare Council (PHWC) report.

With many commercial pig farms having gone out of business over the past decade, NPA chairman Richard Lister, who farms 3,300 indoor sows across four units in North Yorkshire and Nottinghamshire, said the trend towards larger farms was driven by economic reality.

“Small farms are under pressure across all species and price continues to be a major driver. A farm of 2,000 pigs is not necessarily sufficient to employ a full-time person, so, as we are constantly encouraged to become more efficient to compete globally, we need economies of scale,” he said.

The UK’s diversity
In fact, the UK boasts one of the most diverse pig sectors in the world.
The PHWC report showed:
* Around 40% of the commercial pig breeding herd in England is kept outdoors
* Of the remaining 60%, most indoor sows are kept in straw-based systems until farrowing
* 20% of weaners, 5% of growers and 2% of finishers are kept outdoors
* 40% of weaners, 60% of growers and 45% of finishers are kept on straw indoors, with the rest kept on indoor slatted floors.
Research by the NPA has shown this diversity of systems, a major selling point for the UK pig sector at home and abroad, to be unique. “Very few pigs anywhere else in the world, apart from Sweden, are kept outdoors or indoors on straw,” Dr Crayford said.

The UK is unique in the diversity of its pig production systems
The UK is unique in the diversity of its pig production systems

Big isn’t bad
But many people connected to the UK pig industry are adamant that the basis of the ‘big is bad’ argument is deeply flawed anyway.

Take the proposal for a 2,500-sow pig unit at Foston, in Derbyshire – one of the focal points of the ‘factory farm’ opposition movement. The plans set out how investment in the high-tech modern facility would be used to maximise pig welfare at all stages, including 360 farrowing crates, and minimise health risks through, for example, high level biosecurity, state-of-the-art ventilation, quality veterinary care and stockmanship, as well as minimising risks to the local environment, producing renewable energy and supporting the local economy.

Mr Lister said. “There is no evidence at all to suggest that a large farm has poorer welfare than a small farm. A large farm is likely to have more trained staff on site and people there for more hours in the day.”
Annie Davis, a past-president of the Pig Veterinary Society, said opponents of large farms were driven by emotion, not evidence.

“The badly researched, unscientific propaganda from the so-called ‘welfare’ campaign groups, offended by our industry and its economics of scale, adds misleading emotion into the debate, and has little to do with the reality of animal welfare on farm.

“Good and bad farms exist regardless of scale. It is well recognised, from both current experience and scientific evidence, that larger farms are no more likely to have compromised welfare than smaller ones. Put simply, management and stockmanship are the critical factors for animal welfare, not the size of the farm,” she said.

NFU deputy president Minette Batters, Charles Godfray, director of the Oxford Martin Programme on the Future of Food, Richard Griffiths, British Poultry Council chief executive and Christine Nicol, professor of veterinary science at the University of Bristol, all reiterated the message that husbandry, not size of farm, is the key to animal welfare.

Professor Nichol said very densely stocked intensive units can seriously constrain internally motivated behaviours. But spacious, protected, semi-indoor areas with natural light can often be better than small outdoor units – where animals can suffer neglect, particularly in extreme weather – ‘as they allow for the important behaviours while keeping disease risks low’, she said.

The RSPCA agrees that: “It is not the scale of production that, in itself, has an impact on animal welfare, but the conditions under which the animals are kept… welfare can be poor or good on both large and small farms.”

"It is well recognised that larger farms are no more likely than smaller ones to have compromised welfare" - Annie Davis
“It is well recognised that larger farms are no more likely than smaller ones to have compromised welfare” – Annie Davis

Do large farms fuel
antibiotic use?

At a recent conference on antibiotics in farming, Cóilín Nunan, of the Alliance to Save our Antibiotics (ASOA), linked antibiotic use to ‘farming systems and intensification’. While acknowledging antibiotic use can be significantly reduced without changing farming methods, he said ‘lower levels of antibiotic usage could be achieved in organic and other extensive farming systems’.

But, highlighting the progress being made in reducing pig industry usage, Dr Crayford said equating production systems with antibiotic use was “far too simplistic”.

As well as ignoring the ‘wider economic and practical context’ of pig production, it also ignored the benefits of modern, high-tech pig buildings in promoting high herd health. In fact, one reason why countries like the Netherlands and Denmark have been able to reduce usage to such a degree is that those governments have financially supported producers to invest in such facilities that ‘support lower antibiotic usage’, she said.

Embrace the diversity
Mr Lister said: “The diversity of the British pig sector is one of its greatest strengths, offering consumers at home and abroad choice and a range of price points and giving producers more clout in a diverse market.
“But to suggest one system is superior to the other is wrong. We are hugely proud of our animal health and welfare standards and our collective goal must be to promote the very best standards, regardless of size or system, while ensuring we are efficient and competitive in the marketplace.”

Share. LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Email
Previous ArticleChinese pork imports to UK fall
Next Article Processors blamed by IFA for undermining pigmeat market
Alistair Driver

Editor Pig World, group editor Agronomist and Arable Farmer and Farm Contractor. National Pig Association webmaster. Former political editor at Farmers Guardian. Occasional media pundit. Brought up on a Leicestershire farm. Works from a shed in his Oxfordshire garden.

Read Similar Stories

Pigs Tomorrow: The sustainability challenges and trade-offs

June 13, 2025

Pigs Tomorrow: Ever-increasing knowledge informs future of farrowing

June 12, 2025

Pig Tomorrow: Caring for, attracting and keeping staff

June 11, 2025
Latest News

Pig industry veteran Hugh Crabtree awarded MBE

June 16, 2025

AHDB seeking pork sector director, as Angela Christison announces departure

June 16, 2025

Pigs Tomorrow: The sustainability challenges and trade-offs

June 13, 2025
Sponsored Content

THE GATEKEEPER OF RESPIRATORY HEALTH – MYCOPLASMA HYOPNEUMONIAE (M.HYO)

April 30, 2024

Tackle the root cause of PWD with free diagnostic tests

March 1, 2024
Current Pig Industry jobs
  • Pig Stockperson Ref 1753

    • Oxfordshire
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
  • Farrowing Manager

    • Suffolk
    • Blythburgh Pigs
    • Full Time
  • Pig Stockperson – Ref 1752 Somerset

    • Somerset
    • Roadhogs Recruitment Ltd.
    • Full Time
GETTING IN TOUCH
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Meet The Editors
  • About Us
  • Email Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Reuse permissions
OUR SOCIAL CHANNELS
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
PARTNER EVENTS
RELATED SITES
  • Farmers Weekly
  • Agronomist & Arable Farmer
  • Farm Contractor
  • National Pig Awards
  • Pigs Tomorrow
  • Poultry News
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
© 2024 MA Agriculture Ltd, a Mark Allen Group company

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.